Yes. Newer Cincinnati subdivisions are often built on graded fill, and if that fill was not properly compacted, the foundation settles into it over the first several years. New homes also sit on the same expansive clays. Settlement on poorly compacted fill is a common newer-home failure mode.
More detail
New construction is not immune to foundation problems, and in some ways subdivision homes carry a specific risk that older homes do not: settlement on engineered fill that was not adequately compacted. Many newer Greater Cincinnati subdivisions are built on lots that were graded and filled to create a buildable pad, often on sloping or uneven terrain. If that fill was placed and compacted properly, in controlled lifts to a specified density, it performs fine. If it was rushed or under-compacted, it continues to consolidate under the weight of the house for the first several years, and the foundation settles into it, sometimes unevenly. The result shows up as the same symptoms as any settlement: stair-step cracks, sticking doors, sloping floors, and gaps, typically appearing one to five years after construction. On top of the fill issue, new homes sit on the same expansive lacustrine and glacial-till clays as everything else in the region, so they experience the same seasonal swelling and shrinking. Two other newer-home factors: builder-grade drainage that was minimal or has since been disrupted by landscaping, and downspouts and grading that direct water toward rather than away from the foundation. The encouraging part is that newer homes are usually straightforward to repair because the construction is modern and well-documented, and helical or push piers underpin a settling new foundation cleanly. If your newer home is showing settlement signs, it is worth checking whether the builder's warranty still covers structural defects before pursuing a repair, and an engineer's evaluation will document the cause, which matters if a warranty or builder claim is in play.